Comparison · FuturesEdge vs Consistry

FuturesEdge vs Consistry — built for futures. Built on real behavioral math, not a mood tag.

Consistry is a solid multi-firm psychology journal if you trade forex or CFDs across MT4/5 and cTrader — its free tier is genuinely generous.

FuturesEdge is purpose-built for futures prop trading specifically: the behavioral engine (Dr. PET™ 5-pillar score) is trained on the exact failure modes futures evaluations create — daily loss limits, trailing drawdowns, EOD breach mechanics — not a general revenge-trade tag applied across every asset class. And the payout-probability model runs a real Monte Carlo simulation against your firm's specific rules, not a rule-compliance checklist.

FuturesEdgeConsistry
Futures-specific (NinjaTrader/Tradovate)✅Partial (TopstepX only)
Behavioral composite score✅ Trader DNA Score℠ — 5 pillars, 0–1000Discipline Score (single metric)
Payout probability modeling✅ Payout Maximizer™ — Monte Carlo simulation❌
Patent statusProvisional filing in preparation (2026)Not claimed
Firm accountability scoring✅ Prop Sentinel™❌
Free tier2 firms, 60-day historyUnlimited firms + Discipline Score
Paid$29–49/mo$29/mo · $49/mo w/ voice

Comparison reflects publicly available Consistry plans and features as of July 2026. Consistry is a trademark of its respective owner; FuturesEdge is not affiliated with Consistry.

Where Consistry is genuinely good

  • A generous free tier — unlimited trades, unlimited prop firm accounts, a Discipline Score, and cross-challenge memory at $0. For multi-firm forex/CFD traders, that's a real offer, not a teaser.
  • Cross-challenge memory — comparing every challenge you've taken across firms is a genuinely useful idea, well executed.
  • Broad platform sync — MT4/5, cTrader, Match-Trader, DXtrade, and CSV import cover most of the forex/CFD prop world.

Where FuturesEdge goes deeper

  • Futures-first, not futures-eventually — NinjaTrader/Tradovate-centered pipeline and a rule engine built around futures eval mechanics: trailing vs static drawdown, daily loss limits, EOD breach math. Consistry's futures coverage is TopstepX only.
  • Trader DNA Score℠ — 5 pillars, not one number — discipline, tilt stability, sizing, consistency, and payout readiness scored separately (0–1000 composite with named archetypes), instead of a single discipline metric.
  • Compound-tilt detection — detects revenge-trading spirals as they form from re-entry speed and size escalation in your actual fills — not a mood tag you self-report.
  • Payout Maximizer™ — Monte Carlo simulation of your payout probability against your specific firm's rules. A pre-trade rule check tells you if a trade is allowed; this tells you whether you're on track to ever get paid.
  • Prop Sentinel™ — the industry's first crowdsourced firm-accountability tracker: payout denials, rule changes, and account closures, logged and corroborated — the firms get audited too.
See It On Your Own Data

Your discipline has five dimensions.
Score them all.

Start free — 2 firms, no card required. Your first DNA Score takes minutes.

Start Free — No Card Required

THE ALPHA IS IN THE ANALYTICS.™ · FUTURES EDGE AI LLC